Why are you neither complying with our recommendations nor returning them back to us, said the CJI.
Bench headed by CJI Thakur today questioned the Centre as to why recommendations of the collegium on transfer of judges and chief justices of high courts are not being complied.
Bench asked Govt. to file a detailed status report on such pending transfers recommendations with reasons in two weeks.
Court said that Govt’s inaction is giving rise to “speculation and misgivings.”
It said, instead of sitting over the recommendation, the Centre Govt should return them back for reconsideration.
Bench also comprising Justices A M Khanwilkar and D Y Chandrachud said that Govt is sitting over transfers for over 10 months.
AG Rohatgi replied that he needs to take instructions on the pending transfer recommendations and sought three weeks of time for the same.
Senior advocate Ram Jethmalani quiped that the top law officer of the government like AG should have all the information.
Sr. Advocate Jethmalani pointed that transfer recommendation of Justice M R Shah of the Gujarat High Court is pending compliance since February 2016.
Jethmalani said that he do not understand why is the government so interested to keep this man over there.
Yatin Oza, Senior Advocate complained that things are in really such bad shape that he cannot say things in open court with journalists and media listening.
Bench gave Attorney General two weeks time to submit report.
Related News @ LatestLaws.in-
4.12.2016 – CJI T S Thakur’s era on its end as SC Collegium awaits new Chief Justice for important pending decisions
23.11.2016 – SC Collegium reiterates 37 names out of 43 returned for High Court Judgeship: Govt
18.11.2016 – Crisis deepens as SC Collegium trashes Govt.’s rejection of 43 names it had sent for HC Judgeship
6.11.2016 – Modi Govt extends Olive Branch: Accepts CJI Thakur’s proposal on re-employment of Retd. Judges
27.10.2016 – CJI Thakur: In times like today even Justice Krishna Iyer’s would have found elevation to the SC tough
14.10.2016 – Justice J Chelameswar still adamant on not attending SC Collegium with CJI Thakur
22.9.2016 – CJI Thakur: We will resolve all differences with Govt. on Judicial appointments in 2 weeks
2.9.2016 – Sitting SC Justice takes Supreme Court head on, questions Collegium’s way of Judges appointment
18.9.2016- CJI Thakur extends Olive Branch, meets and greets PM Modi on his Birthday
4.9.2016- CJI Thakur in defensive mode post outburst by Justice Chelameswar, says will ‘Sort it out’
26.8.2016- CJI Thakur: Can’t bring Ram Rajya, I am also shedding tears of Blood on plight of the Nation
23.8.2016- CJI Thakur gets an Ally in Nobel Laureate Satyarthi in his War with Govt. on Judges appointment
20.8.2016- CJI Thakur feels: Unpolluted, Speedy Justice remains a distant dream for our Citizens
15.8.2016- CJI Thakur rues PM’s silence on Judiciary’s woes in Red Fort speech, said situation worse than British Raj
14.8.2016- Rahul jumps in Judiciary-Modi Govt. War: Sides with CJI Thakur, takes on Modi for SC castigation
13.8.2016- War between Judiciary and Govt. escalates: SC warns Govt. do not think that we are a ‘Panchayat’
12.8.2016- CJI Thakur’s poser to Modi: Do you want Judiciary to come to a Grinding halt