Home / Latest News / NJAC hearing: Supreme Court takes note of LK Advani’s remarks on Emergency

NJAC hearing: Supreme Court takes note of LK Advani’s remarks on Emergency

June,21,2015: The Supreme Court on Friday took note of senior BJP leader LK Advani's remarks that another Emergency couldn't be ruled out during a debate on the legality of the government's ambitious twin laws that replace the collegium system of appointing judges with the National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC).

Supreme Court of India
Supreme Court of India

"It's being said that there will be a repeat of Emergency," said Justice JS Khehar, in line to be chief justice India and head of the fivemember constitutional bench. He made the observation when senior constitutional expert and lead counsel for those opposing the NJAC, Fali S Nariman, insisted that the NJAC laws sought to whittle away at judicial independence in a manner similar to what the Congress party wanted when it had a majority in the years after Independence.

"This is the first majority government in 30 years after several minority governments," he said. "There was a Nath Pal in the Congress who wanted all sorts of amendments when the Congress had three fourths majority. Now comes the second party which will be in power for the next five or 10 years. What is this experimentation?" The bench wondered if the court shouldn't first wait for the implementation of the NJAC before taking a call on the legality as the government was demanding.

"Then we will be finished," Nariman said. "That is why the basic structure doctrine came about, to put a stop to this. Otherwise there would have been a queen even if not a king in this country. Every go vernment wants judges as lackeys. There will be toadyism if this goes through. It is insidious, revolutionary and unnecessary. Judges will then hobnob, lobby with the government."

The other four members of the bench are Justices Jasti Chelameswar, Madan B Lokur, Kurian Joseph and Adarsh Goel. Nariman rejected the government's contention that the president would rubber stamp decisions of the council of ministers on judges' appointments. "If the president is a dummy, he can't ask the CJIThis is erroneous. He can have a dialogue with the CJI. He shouldn't be a dummy," he said. 

ET

RELATED NEWS-  

                      11.6.15- Centre tears into SC Collegium system READ MORE…

                              5.5.15- Centre, SC spar over primacy of CJI in judicial appointments READ MORE…

                              2.5.15- Lay citizens cannot select judges, says SC READ MORE…

                              1.5.15- Did Centre, collegium ever differ? Asks SC READ MORE…

                             27.4.15- Will not participate in NJAC, CJI Justice Dattu tells Modi READ MORE…

                             23.4.15-  NJAC will not appoint judges till SC decides on validity READ MORE…

                              21.4.15- SC to decide which 5 judges can hear NJAC validity READ MORE…

                             15.4.15-  Justice Dave recuse himself from hearing petitions challenging NJAC Act READ MORE…

                             15.4.15- Premature to test constitutionality of NJAC, Govt. to plead before SCREAD MORE…

                             13.4.15- Govt. notifies NJAC, spells end to Supreme Court Collegium READ MORE…

                               9.4.15- National Judicial Appointments Commission rollout may take monthsREAD MORE…

                               7.4.15- SC refers NJAC Act validity issue to larger bench READ MORE…

 

 

                                  

Facebook Comments

Check Also

Housing for Poor

Govt might allow building of an extra floor in order to push Housing for Poor

Govt might allow building of an extra floor in order to push Housing for Poor

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *