Home / Latest News / Supreme Court- Evidence & finding recorded by the Criminal Courts in a Criminal proceeding cannot be the conclusive proof of existence of any fact in Civil Cases

Supreme Court- Evidence & finding recorded by the Criminal Courts in a Criminal proceeding cannot be the conclusive proof of existence of any fact in Civil Cases

September, 5,2015: Supreme Court bench of Justices M.Y. Eqbal  and C. Nagappan lately held that the evidence and the finding recorded by the criminal courts in a criminal proceeding cannot be the conclusive proof of existence of any fact.

SC
SC

In the instant case, the trial court had come to the conclusion that the plaintiff is not entitled to get the specific performance as it failed to prove that the agreement of sale dated 2.9.1967 was executed by the defendants, reason being that the alleged agreement was executed in a quarter sheet of paper written in small letters. The High Court, on appeal reversed this finding by trial court and  said quarter sheet of paper was produced before the Magistrate in a criminal proceeding. The High Court held that the agreement was produced before the Criminal Court wherein, plaintiff  was prosecuted on the charge of trespass and the Criminal Court having examined the said document has made certain observations with reference to such document and that being so, when the very same document sought to be questioned in a Civil case, the observations by a Criminal Court will certainly have relevance. The defendants approached the Supreme Court against this judgment of the High Court.

The Supreme Court held “In our view, the High Court is not correct in holding that there is no reason to  disbelieve the execution of the document although it was executed on a quarter sheet of paper and not on a proper stamp and also written in a small letter. The High Court also misdirected itself in law in holding that there was no need of the plaintiff to have sought for the opinion of an expert regarding the execution of the document.”

The Court should meticulously consider all facts and circumstances of the case and to see that it is not used as an instrument of oppression to have an unfair advantage not only to the plaintiff but also to the defendant qua the existence of agreement to grant a decree for specific performance without independent finding recorded by the Civil Court.It also said that the High Court failed to consider the scope of Section 20 of the Specific Relief Act and the law laid down by Supreme Court.

Read Full Text of the Judgment-

 

Supreme Court- Evidence & finding recorded by the Criminal Courts in a Criminal proceeding cannot be th…

Related Links-

2.9.2015 – SC rules Accused not to be denied Anticipatory Bail despite addition of serious offence during Trial READ MORE…

1.9.2015 – SC advise Centre Govt. to Petition International Court of Justice to bring back Indian POWs from Pakistan Jails READ MORE…

31.8.2015 – Supreme Court intervenes to save ‘Santhara’ after Rajasthan High Court banned it READ MORE…

30.8.2015 – Supreme Court instructs Central Govt- Your Policy and Laws for Old People have aged, update them READ MORE…

29.8.2015 – Supreme Court barb for Govt. ‘Welfare Schemes running only on paper’READ MORE…

27.8.2015 – Supreme Court commandment “Procedures shall always be subservient to Justice” READ MORE…

23.8.2015 – Supreme Court fumes, castigates Delhi Police Commissioner and issues contempt for not Arresting the Accused on NBWs & instead sermonizing the Court READ MORE…

22.8.2015 – Courts can do no harm to citizens, says Supreme Court READ MORE…

20.8.2015 – Supreme Court warns High Courts against undue sympathy towards convicts & arbitrary exercise of judicial discretion READ MORE…

4.8.2015 – Supreme Court says, No relief of Discharge for Accused summoned by Criminal Courts U/s 319 CrPC READ MORE…

Facebook Comments

Check Also

Ram Jethmalani gives Kejriwal shock of his life

Sr. Adv. Jethmalani quits as Kejriwal’s counsel, seeks ₹2 Crore fee

Sr. Adv. Jethmalani quits as Kejriwal's counsel, seeks ₹2 crore fee

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *